The caldera-forming Rotoiti eruption from Okataina volcano was one of the largest rhyolite events of the last 100ka in the Taupo Volcanic Zone, New Zealand. Its associated widespread tephra layer (Rotoehu tephra) is a significant time marker in terrestrial-marine paleoclimate correlation studies in the SW Pacific. However, the accurate and precise age of this eruption, and of the subsequent, smaller volume Earthquake Flat (EQF) eruption, has been the subject of controversy despite numerous studies. We have applied combined ²³⁸U/ ²³ºTh disequilibrium and (U-Th)/He dating of zircon from Rotoiti and EQF deposits, and obtained overlapping ages of 45.1(7)±3.3ka and 45.1(6)±2.9ka, respectively. These results are supported by new and published high-precision radiocarbon data bracketing the age of the Rotoiti eruption between 44.8±0.3 and 47.5±2.1ka cal BP. These age data are also in good agreement with a range of previously published estimates based on paleoclimate (palynology), luminescence dating of enclosing sediment, and sedimentation rates in terrestrial and marine settings. However, these results are at variance with a commonly quoted age of ~60ka, largely constrained by a single ⁴ºAr/ ³⁹Ar age of an overlying glassy lava flow at a distal tephra site. This study demonstrates the potential for combined ²³⁸U/ ²³ºTh disequilibrium and (U-Th)/He dating of zircon in tephra and other volcanic deposits to provide age control in the 40-100ka time interval, a period difficult to constrain using more traditional radiocarbon, K/Ar and ⁴ºAr/ ³⁹Ar methods.