An exploration of different outlooks on science: towards an understanding of the under-representation of girls, and of Maori and Pacific Island students, in science

Abstract

The research reported here was undertaken as a supplementary study to the Learning in Science Project conducted at Waikato University (1979-1981) and sought to understand why girls, Maori and Pacific Island students, are under-represented in the sciences. Two distinctive, but complementary, perspectives were developed; one qualitative, the other quantitative, to provide data from which an understanding of the problem was sought. The qualitative perspective was provided by using a Kelly Repertory Grid methodology and intensive individual interviews with 26 students (and many of their parents) carefully chosen to provide a reasonably heterogeneous sample of students from a variety of different schools, of both sexes, of the three major ethnic groups (European, Maori, and Pacific Island), and from each of the four middle-school form levels (Fl to F4, inclusively). The quantitative perspective was provided by a series of empirical measures chosen, not only to identify the students for the qualitative sample but also, to investigate particular variables suggested by the literature search to have possible implications for the teaching and learning of science. The resultant analyses suggested the sex differences in the students’ outlooks on science could be accounted for by the existence of a broad based ‘gender-related inequality’ in the way science is presented to them by the communication media, home, and school. Similarly, the ethnic differences in students’ outlooks on science could be accounted for by the ‘cultural inequality’ present in New Zealand society which was identified in the way many of the Polynesian students and their parents, perceived the products, processes, and practitioners of science. The simplification presented here masks the complexity of the issues involved but, series of educational within these two broad postulates, a series of educational recommendations was suggested for affecting current educational practices identified as maintaining (or even creating) the existing under-representation of girls, Maori and Pacific Island students in the sciences. These included: (i) Student beliefs about science need to be explored, challenged, modified, and/or extended (ii) Students’ perceptions of other people’s views need to be identified, explored, challenged and/or extended (iii) Teachers’ styles of teaching science need to be examined (iv) Parents’ own outlooks on science need to be developed. This research has emphasised the need to have all students, but particularly girls, Maori, and Pacific Island students, develop positive outlooks on science in order that the current imbalance of girls and Polynesians in the sciences be redressed.