Loading...
Abstract
Leadership ethics, shaped by diverse cultures, religious beliefs, and philosophical perspectives, exhibit nuanced differences between Western and Eastern perspectives. Despite these differences, ethical leadership scales predominantly adhere to Western conceptualisations, overlooking the unique cultural nuances of the East. The cultural traditions, philosophical views, and religious beliefs in the Eastern world imply culturally specific ethical leadership characteristics that may not align with Western-centric measures. This underscores the need for a comprehensive conceptualisation and scale development for Eastern Ethical Leadership (EEL) that captures the underlying values specific to the East. Drawing on the culturally implicit leadership theory, this thesis aims to address the following research questions, with an overarching focus on conceptualising and developing a scale for EEL:
(1) What is the current state of ethical leadership literature as it pertains to Eastern countries?
(2) What are the dimensions and measures of ethical leadership which are applicable to Eastern
countries?
(3) What is the validity of these measures across Eastern countries?
To address these research questions, three major studies were conducted. Initially, a systematic review of literature on EEL was performed, revealing the distinct characteristics of EEL and the cultural and philosophical perspectives that distinguish it from the West. Following the Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis (PRISMA) framework, the review identified relevant articles from four academic databases, revealing unique dimensions of EEL. These dimensions include leaders' responsibility and concern for long-term sustainability, aspects often overlooked in existing measures. Notably, while some virtues and values align between Eastern and Western philosophical views, past studies predominantly relied on Western theoretical perspectives to interpret ethical leadership. This underscores the need for measures that authentically capture Eastern cultural distinctions, essential for advancing ethical leadership research amidst the East's growing global influence.
The second study reports a qualitative investigation based on interviews with 21 academics across 15 Asian countries to deepen our understanding of EEL characteristics. Thematic analysis of the interview data unveiled culturally specific elements contributing to the conceptualisation of ethical leadership in the East. The findings highlighted the significance of characteristics identified by interviewees, shaped by the societal context of Asian countries. For example, caring for individuals emerges as a crucial characteristic in collectivist societies, along with demonstrating concern for the welfare of the broader community, particularly in regions facing widespread poverty. Furthermore, the perspectives shared by interviewees offer valuable insights that challenge prevalent Western-dominated views on ethical leadership.
Thirdly, a robust measure for EEL was developed and validated through a rigorous process. This study encompassed item generation based on literature and qualitative interviews, scale purification, cross-cultural validity testing, and an assessment of the psychometric properties of the scale. The developed scale was then applied to examine its impact on employee voice behaviour, serving as a crucial step in testing its nomological validity and providing valuable insights into the practical implications of EEL. The dimensions of EEL identified, including concern for people and concern for wider views, exclusively reflect the cultural nuances of the East and challenge the broad applicability of Western-centric ethical leadership measures, advocating for a more culturally nuanced understanding.
The thesis challenges the prevailing bias in ethical leadership literature towards the West, offering a culturally grounded measure for EEL that enhances conceptual development. The theoretical and practical implications of the scale are discussed, highlighting its potential to bridge the cultural gap in leadership ethics and contribute to the development of a more inclusive and culturally resonant leadership paradigm. Three separate research articles, derived from the systematic review, qualitative study, and scale development, have been submitted to peer-reviewed journals, reflecting the comprehensive approach taken in this endeavour. The outcomes of this research contribute not only to the academic discourse on ethical leadership but also offer practical insights for organisations operating in culturally diverse contexts.
Type
Thesis
Type of thesis
Series
Citation
Date
2024-10-15
Publisher
The University of Waikato
Supervisors
Rights
All items in Research Commons are provided for private study and research purposes and are protected by copyright with all rights reserved unless otherwise indicated.